Wattree's picture

    Trayvon Martin is Dead Because He Was Born Black in America - Period

    White conservatives often criticize Black people for being too quick to play what they call "the race card." On the other hand, many Black people criticize America for not being sensitive enough to the reality that race plays in American life. George Zimmerman’s trial for the murder of Trayvon Martin clearly validates the Black community’s point of view.

    Trayvon Martin is dead for no other reason than he was born Black in America. That’s a non-debatable fact. Had he been a White kid, Trayvon would have still been alive today. Yet, even as the jury is out deliberating Zimmerman’s fate, there’s a raging debate going on in America over whether or not Zimmerman was justified in taking this mere child’s life.
    .
    Regardless to the eventual verdict in this case, the trial itself clearly demonstrates how the laws of the land are routinely bent against the interest of the Black community while still managing to maintain the illusion of justice for all.
    .
    The bottom line is, Trayvon Martin was guilty of absolutely nothing. He was simply engaged in an activity that millions of kids - good kids - engage in all across this country on a daily basis. He wasn’t casing the neighborhood in preparation to commit a crime, he wasn’t walking down the street smoking dope, nor was he walking the street in search of a potential victim. He was simply an innocent kid on his way home after going to the store to buy a bag of Skiddles and a soft drink. So how, in a just society, can he end up dead, and his killer - an armed adult, who stalked him, and outweighed him by forty pounds - can now be claiming self-defense in his murder? The very scenario strains credulity to the limit.
    .
    One would think the facts above would be crystal clear to every single person in America - and they would be if the situation was exactly reversed. If Trayvon Martin had been the adult in this scenario, and he stalked and killed a White kid under the exact same circumstances - if he stalked the kid, weighed forty pounds more than his victim, and he was armed while the kid was not - chances are, he would already be on Death Row for First Degree Murder - that is, assuming he survived to reach the police station.
    .
    In addition, what many are failing to realize is, by trying to bend the law to accommodate their racism they're cutting their own throats. You see, many people think an assault is a physical attack, but that's not true. An assault is simply putting a person in fear of bodily harm? So what most people think of as an assault - physically attacking someone - is actually an assault and battery. So when Zimmerman confronted Trayvon and made him fear for his well being, that constituted an assault. Therefore, he committed a crime against Trayvon, and Trayvon had every right to defend himself. So if Trayvon would have had a gun and shot Zimmerman he would have been well within his rights. Thus, if Zimmerman is found not guilty, that will set a precedent saying that if a guy tries to rob you and you fight back, he has a right to kill you in self-defense.
    .
    While one might say, that doesn't apply since the guy is engaged in a  criminal act, who will be around to attest to that?  Just like Trayvon, you'll be dead, so there will only be the criminal's word for what took place. Therefore, if Zimmerman is found not guilty of this grievous crime, it will not only be a slap in the face of justice, Trayvon Martin, and the Black community, but it'll be an assault on the personal security of every American across this land.  In fact, it may even give criminals an incentive to kill in order to cover-up their crimes.
    .
    That's a high price to pay to accommodate racism, but in spite of that, I don’t take the position that all White people are malevolent, nor am I one who's prone to looking under every rock for the existence of racism whenever Black people don’t get their way. I do, however, stand firm in the belief that racism is such an historically pervasive part of American life that many Americans - both Black and White - harbor grossly racist attitudes towards Black people that are so deeply ingrained that they don’t even recognize it themselves.
    .
    You don’t think so? Watch any hip hop video and count the number of beautiful dark-skinned sisters you find. I guarantee you, you’ll find very few - and even when a dark-skinned sister is so strikingly beautiful that they can’t avoid using her, they’ll usually shine a light on her to make her look orange.
    .
    So I reiterate, Trayvon Martin is dead due to the gross racism of a grossly racist society - Period.
    .
    Eric L. Wattree
    Http://wattree.blogspot.com
    [email protected]
    Citizens Against Reckless Middle-Class Abuse (CARMA)
    .
    Religious bigotry: It's not that I hate everyone who doesn't look, think, and act like me - it's just that God does.
     

    Comments

    The idea that a young Black male can be afraid or have a right to defend his own life does seem foreign to many.


    I imagine that if Trayvon had been Troy the white kid, that Zimmerman never would have followed him in the first place.  But, maybe I'm wrong about that.  Maybe Zimmerman had a more equal opportunity paranoia.

    Had he fought and shot Troy the white kid, he would have been arrested that night and probably kept in custody for awhile, if not until trial.  He would not have been free, raising money online for his defense and concocting his story.  It just wouldn't have happened that way.  

    Now, lets take it a step further and make our victim Troy not only white but from a rich, rather than middle class family.  This family would have its own lawyers and investigators augmenting the state's case.  The family would have political influence over the prosecutor's office.  I think we'd be talking less about whether Zimmerman was justified and more about whether or not he was going to face life in prison or the ultimate punishment.

    The system is corrupted by both race and class.  Zimmerman killed a middle class black kid and the "hero or criminal" debate is still being had, as if Zimmerman had done something morally ambiguous in the manner of Edward Snowden.

     


    I personally have been avoiding this topic or saying anything about it but I will say.... I retweeted this to over 500 followers on Twitter. wink


    @Michael,

    I totally agree with you - and can you imagine how the scenario would have played out if George Zimmerman would have been George Brotherman, and Trayvon would have been Troy the 17 year-old White kid!!!!?

    .

    @Orion,

    Thank you so much. I put a lot of thought into whether or not I should publish this prior to the verdict because I want it to be insightful rather than "inciteful" (sic). But I decided that the former would be better served if I published prior to the verdict.


    Sheesh, I guess my imagination has its blind spots.  I didn't even consider the obvious scenario.  A middle class black man arms himself to protect his neighborhood.  He has the same interests Zimmerman did.  The exact same motives.

    But you wonder if he survives his arrest, much less all of this happening.


    Whenever racial issues come up, I get very extreme and a bit on the ugly side. I had to delete a bunch of comments on a racially charged thread after my comments broke Terms of Service. It's a fine line, of course, but you know.


    It's times like these when I am very glad that we have Wattree's voice here.  It's really a gift for us.  You can do it, but I can't write with his authenticity on these issues.


    Thanks but I am still a white guy. Just because I have diverse backgrounds and experiences doesn't mean I necessarily know what it's like to move around in this difficult world and country with dark skin. Wattree is certainly a bit more valid than I am.


    Heh.  Me neither.  But you do write well from the perspective of the "other," on a whole lot of levels.  Really, though, I think that Dag is fortunate to have attracted Wattree, who has a voice that you do not necessarily hear on other blogs of this type.


    Here is a former Florida US Attorney who sees the armed Zimmerman as the one at fault. Chris Hayes had a panel discussing the Zimmerman trial. I turned the sound off and turned on XM Radio..Too much pain.

    I turned the sound back on when he discussed the Tampon confiscation in the Texas Senate.


    Man the optics coming out of Texas is really going to hurt the Republicans.  Did they really think there was going to be an organized throwing of those items? LOL  Texas State House takes the prize for stupid.


    Sadly as a mostly white American I have to agree that racism definitely remains a massive and ugly problem in our society. 

    I don't think Trayvon died 'just' because he was black...  I think he died because he was black and he lived in Florida where they have a 'stand your ground' law.  Zimmerman knew about this law and he used it...  though I have to wonder how much racism is behind the law itself.  But Trayvon also died because he happen to cross paths with a bigoted armed man that wanted to be a cop. 

    My intuition is that the jury will return with a verdict of manslaughter though I don't think that is true justice in this case.

     


    Stand your ground was on the NRA wish list and lobbied hard for it.  There are many gun shows in Florida and retirees that collect and sale guns.  It took several tries to get this law passed and I think is was a compromise to get something else pass.  Law enforcement don't like it because it is poorly written and too broad. This leads to problems for the officers who are on the scene.  It was sold as a way to shoot someone outside of your home for protection with out making efforts to get away from them.  Before you had to shoot them and drag them into your house on self defense.  Otherwise you could face an assortment of charges based on the situation even though it was self defense and you were afraid for your life.  Most of the cases that have gone to court under stand your ground, has been drug dealers shooting each other.  It makes it hard to prosecute when some one claims self defense. As soon as it became law self defense cases doubled.  It was passed even with an organized opposition.  I remember the TV adds that showed Florida turning into the Wild West. If Zimmermen gets off, this law will become a issue in the Florida Governor's race.  The Republicans will own this one and the southern half of the state is in the process of turning blue.    


    All of this is true, Wattree. But it's worth saying, again and again.

    What's instructive is how hard people work NOT to see the obvious in this case.


    I tend to see complexity where it doesn't exist but, yeah, this is ridiculous.


    What people fail to realize is, an assault is simply putting a person in fear of bodily harm? Actually touching them is assault and BATTERY. So when Zimmerman confronted Trayvon and scared him, that constituted an assault. Therefore, he committed a crime against Trayvon and Trayvon had a right to defend himself. So if Trayvon would have had a gun and shot Zimmerman he would have been within his rights. Thus, if Zimmerman is found innocent, that will set a precedent saying that if a guy tries to rob you and you fight back, he has a right to kill you in self-defense.

    People need to think about that. We're electing legislators for purely political purposes without stopping to consider that many of them are functionally illiterate and they're flooding the books with crazy laws. Now Sarah Palin wants to be a senator. I guess she saw Capitol Hill from her backyard.

     

     

     


    I didn't know the assault definition either.  I guess another implication, if the law condones Zimmerman, is that in any state where a person can carry a gun, particularly if concealed, you have basically normalized "stop and frisk" amongst citizens.  So, if I take a late night walk and some stranger follows me and starts asking questions about where I'm going and where I've been, I'll have to be polite about being harassed.  We will have deputized the world's Zimmermans.


    Terrible for you. My wife only had a stranger follow her along a large well-lit boulevard late at night and try to  pull her into the bushes to rape her and when she slipped out of her jacket he ran after her but she got away. Being questioned about where you were going must have been really traumatic.

    (By the way, the police's response was to question her about what she was wearing and why she was walking by herself after midnight, and after 45 minutes of questioning they went driving around to see if they saw anything.)


    Lucky she didn't have any outstanding parking tickets.

    A friend was ticketed after having the car totaled by a speeding big rig on an icy Michigan highway. License sticker was about 10 days overdue for payment. Cops love to go after the easy targets that fall into their lazy blue clutches.


    Heh heh heh. Yep, I'm sure they looked around our flat for any joints or anything else to bust as well. Much easier than going patrolling for criminals.


    Maybe you didn't mean it this way, but what you wrote really comes off sounding like, "Because my wife had this really horrific thing happen to her, you should be ashamed to complain about anything else less horrific." What happened to your wife was horrific, but that does not mean that someone should feel like they have to answer prying questions from every random stranger who feels entitled to ask them.


    Oh please, the point was that I would be happy if someone checked out the guy doing the trolling - not to give him the 3rd degree, but basic neighborhood maintenance.

    I found a homeless guy locked in the trash closet inside the building where he'd been sleeping and got locked in. Some kids got into the building late at night, too drunk to make it home.  I got them out building, but since it was the public area, not my own apartment, so I guess I should have just minded my own business.

    So asking a simple "visiting someone?" is too much to help avoid rapes and break-ins. Funny, the police's questions to my wife were much more intrusive than that.


    Maybe people could mind their own business?  I don't have to answer to anyone about where I am or why.  And, if I am stalked or followed or harassed, neighborhood watch or no, there will be a problem.


    Someone being stalked felt fear and escaped being raped. Another person who was stalked wound up getting shot. Train your Black sons how to shot under pressured situations


    You are correct Trayvon had the right to Stand his ground and defend himself.  So if he did hit Zimmerman he was defending himself.  If he would have been older and in possession of a gun he could have shot Zimmerman on the stand your ground law.

    Zimmerman should not be able to use the law because most of these laws state you cannot be the aggressor, you cannot start the altercation.


    I just heard the verdict and I am beyond disappointed. I can't express it.  It is infuriating and sickening.  I know that the jury was not presented with everything that we know about Zimmerman and Trayvon.  Zimmerman may belong behind bars for many offenses in truth but this verdict was not justice.  I don't buy 'not guilty' for one second.


    I think the prosecution made a massive error in charging him with 2nd degree murder instead of manslaughter. To much energy and focus was spent on that so the case for manslaughter wasn't really made, it was just added as an after thought.

    I would have found him not guilty of 2nd degree murder but guilty of manslaughter. By over reaching the prosecution didn't make a firm case for manslaughter.


    Agree re: "massive error". If they had focused on manslaughter, they might have been convincing. Speculating on Zimmerman's intent was counter-productive. The defense destroyed their effort to portray him as an out-of-control obnoxious vigilante.


    This verdict has just made every fist fight in America into a gun fight, and made Florida, if not the nation, into a more dangerous place.

    He who brings a gun to the fist fight wins, over the dead body of the other. Go out armed or don't go at all.


    This is a dangerous place; and we were supposed to be the safest place in the world.

    Now they just made all entrants into the Texas Legislature hand in their feminine deodorant products but anyone, anyone could just walk into the great State House with guns?

    This is nuts.

    I would never go to Texas again.

    I really would not!

    You take a gun into a fistfight!

    Well, if the other guy dies.....?

    This is really strange.

    But I do not blame the jury on this mess.

    I really do not blame the prosecution either.

    Beyond a reasonable doubt.

    Oh well....


    At least the Sanford Homeowners Association reportedly paid $1 million to Trayvon's family. They need better police, not armed psycho vigilantes.


    Posting again:  NAACP has a petition up requesting the Dept of Justice open a Civil Rights case on this.  I signed it and left a personal note on the petition.  Sign it and pass it on.  I agree with NAACP that Martin's civil rights have been violated.   http://www.naacp.org/page/s/doj-civil-rights-petition?source=GZnotguiltyshareTAF&utm_medium=email&utm_source=taf&utm_campaign=GZnotguiltyshareTAF


    Just to let you know rallies have been going on because of this verdict.  It is after 1 in the morning and many are still standing around talking about it in this small town.  I think Florida just turned another shade deeper blue.  The college kids just got back from Walmart and told me about it.  This has struck a very deep vein here in Florida.  I think we are going to see a lot of people in the streets over this for the next 24 hours.   


    Thank you for the petition, Trk. I, literally, had to go into my stash of Xanax over this verdict. I was beginning to hyperventilate. And just think, many of the people who are celebrating this gross injustice are sitting up in church this morning claiming to love God.  Go figure it. But if there is indeed such a thing as Karma, many of the people who are celebrating this verdict today, will be rethinking it at some point in the future.


    Latest Comments