Mortimus's picture

    The NFL Combine - A Rant

    Right now over 300 college kids are parading around in sponsored spandex performing the President's Fitness Challenge for a bunch of googley eyed grown men. Well-paid football professionals and numbers geeks are oohing and aahing over tenths of a second in an effort to figure out which specimen they'll hand over the $50 million "Deal or No Deal" briefcase. Endless numbers of greased up Mel Kiper wannabees are plotting these numbers into formulas trying to find the NFL equivalent of e=mc2. Here's a tip: You can slice and dice these digits all you want, but when the digits don't mean anything the only solution you'll come up with is that you are wasting your fucking time.

    Imagine if we held a combine for NBA prospects and we judged them by the speed of their 'suicide sprints' or by a tense game of "horse" (no dunking allowed of course). Or for baseball players we measured their prospective power hitting ability by how fast they can swing their arm submerged in an above ground pool.

    Part of me thinks this is some large conspiracy by the entire NFL scout community who doesn't feel like breaking down game film of 200+ schools. Simple numbers are much easier to organize on Microsoft Excel then say something like intangibles or I don't know...talent! So to make it easier they pull out their handy dandy stop watch, yell "go" 1...2...3...4...5 "nope, no good, next and go" 1...2...3...4.4.25 "WOAH, jot that kid's name down. 4.25! You can't teach that!"

    It reminds me of when I used to pull out my large black casio keyboard watch (aka chick magnet), switch on the stopwatch function and see how quickly I could click it on and off. (for the record I broke .08 once) This 40-yard dash serves about the same amount of purpose. Here's a crazy idea, why not have these players run in pads? You know the stuff they actually play in? And why not have them run with a couple of obstacles (oh I don't know, say some guy bumping them on the line?), and after they have done cardio for the last 2 1/2 hours. I'm sure my 9 year old niece would be awfully competitive with me in a foot race, though I'm quite confident that if we strapped 15 pounds of foam and hardened plastic onto her frame she wouldn't stand a chance. Now if we both had to in pads plow through a 230 lb linebacker after moving furniture for the last 150 minutes to get to those 40 yards, I like my chances.

    Now to test strength they use the bench press. What better way to determine the physical strength of a player in a sport dominated by leverage than by testing how strong their breasts are? It's a completely archaic measuring tool. All I can envision are these 600 NFL scouts equipped with massive chests and itty bitty legs roaming the combine grounds going up to players and asking them like that Emilio Estevez SNL Skit "Hey you, how much ya bench?" ... "You! the All-American Fred Biletnikoff winner, I don't care about your stats, answer one thing: How much ya bench?" I suppose if everyone in the NFL was a paraplegic lining up on the line of scrimmage plopped in their motorized scooter it might come in handy, but we haven't gotten there yet. If the NFL really wanted to beef up their scouting they'd have players do squats or dead lifts - exercises that actually incorporate 3/4 of your body rather than just your tits.

    Let me tell you a story about a kid I knew in high school. He was a brainy fellow, with a body the consistency of lemon merengue custard. He was a whiz on the black and ivory keys and could play the meanest baddest version of the Charlie Brown theme song that you've ever heard. So come gym fitness test time (we didn't have to wear spandex) our teacher tried to see who could bench 225lbs. A few of the guys on the football team were able to do it, while most failed. However, this soon to be Yale grade who probably only associated "Crunch" with a Nestle Bar accomplished the task with ease and for the rest of his tenure paraded around the high school halls with his "I Benched 225lbs" manly man t-shirt with fatboy pride. It was the biggest 'FU' to the jock community outside of graduation day. 1,400 teenagers soon figured out that the test didn't mean shit, yet the most lucrative sport in the U.S. still hasn't had their unathletic geek benching 225 moment. Well allow me to illuminate one for them.

    Last season the Jets drafted Vernon Gholston, a guy with the physique of what I envision Adonis having if he drank three daily Androstenedione Slushee Big Gulps and had roids pumping through his body 24/7 on an IV drip. They were so enthralled with his 40-time and his 37 reps of 225lb bench press that they took him with the #6 pick and threw $40 million at him. He responded with all of 13 tackles. Yes, he barely registered half a tackle for each million in his $21 million signing bonus gift card. You want to know how that was possible? Its because HE DIDNT KNOW HOW TO PLAY FOOTBALL!!! The guy didn't know how to use his body nor could understand what the hell the offense was doing on any single play. Of course, if you told him to line up and run in a straight line the guy was a maestro. Nobody is better at sitting on a bench and lifting something repetitively than Vernon. Next year, during week 11 with 3:12 left in the 3rd quarter when the Chargers and Jets go at the "lifting steel several time" competition, we will own them!!!

    So in conclusion, any GM (especially one who wears a green starter jacket) who gets approached by their scouts about prospects who had a 4.3 or a terrific shuttle do the NFL loving community and I a favor - Fire them and tell them that they are wasting your fucking time.

     

    To subscribe to my blog click here: Subscribe

     

    Topics: 

    Comments

    well, obviously, scouts just use combine results as one input in their decision-making process. and of course for every gholston there's a chris johnson whose stellar combine stats appropriately move them up the draft chart.

    more importantly, wow, you did the stop/start casio watch competition too??? and i thought i was the only one (i dont know what my time record was, but just for grins, im going to say it was better than yours).

    and i didn't know you graduated from yale Laughing


    Do you really want to play this game? Give me the top 40-times of the last decade and I'll show you a list of overrated busts.


    AYE!!!

     

    some of us are just watching the "men-in-tights" and getting off on their well sculptured bodies.........and anything else that's swingin.

     

    you know the drill.


    Before giving a player Millions of dollars in any sport, I'd want to know their Wonderlick intelligence score, their understanding and ability to learn the game through a course of interviews, and yes, what kind of shape they are in without their shirt on and thru a series of strength and speed tests.  The combine is much more than just how fast can you run the 40...that's a very simplistic way to look at it, just to be provocative I surmise.  The combine gathers all the top players together and allows all the coaches to meet/speak with all of the players they have interest in....if you think about it, it's a very Green event because it cuts down on those players being flown to several diff. cities to meet with several diff. teams and coaches through the springtime...so the combine actually cuts down on CO2 emissions!


    I agree somewhat (the interview and intelligence test are certainly valuable - hi, Vince!) - but football is mostly instincts, spacial processing, guts and determination. The combine is more than the 40 time but that is the most overused aspect of it and if any one of these participants runs a 4.12 tomorrow (no matter what they've done in college) they jump immediately into the first round and that's ridiculous. I've never considered the "green" aspect of it, though I think there isn't much of a carbon footprint for scouts hitting forward and rewind on the game film - still I I have no doubt that the combine will smartly be branded eco-friendly in the coming years. You wouldn't by any chance be in NFL Marketing would you? If not, you should be.

    I agree with you about the bench and the 40 times.

    In the 40, of course, one is not wearing pads or cleats and they are also starting from a different stance than they would on the field. They are also not running with a football

    Here is something else about the 40 that you alluded to. It's the willingness of a player to run full speed in the middle of 21 other moving players.

    Our fastest high school football player played at tailback but he also rode the bench except for mop up duty. The reason he could never make as tailback as because he ran tentatively(or as our coach would say-he like to tiptoe through the tulips). He was afraid of running into someone at full speed or looking to dodge someone who was running at him full speed.

    Our starting tailback, who gained over a 1000 yards 2 years in a row was slower in the 40. But he a fearless player and ran at full speed, unafraid of the hits or smashing into someone.

    A lot of people are a lot faster on the field, running with reckless abandon, and going all out even if they are dog tired.

    You can't capture that in a 40 yard dash.

    Good blog post.


    Latest Comments