Wattree's picture

    Black People: Don’t Buy Into the Great American Myth

    Beneath the Spin * Eric L. Wattree

     

    Black People: Don’t Buy Into the Great American Myth

    .

    One of the biggest problems that we have in the Black community is how we allow ourselves to be portrayed in the media. There tends to be a blanket profiling of Black people by the media as little more than dysfunctional hood rats with a few functional Black people sprinkled in for the sake of appearance, but as aberrations, and the poverty pimps among us have a vested interest in perpetuating that myth in order to feather their own nests.
    .
    But the fact is, the truth is just the reverse. According to the U. S. Census Bureau, the vast majority of Black people in this country are middle class or above. African Americans are the second largest consumer group in America with a combined buying power of over $892 billion currently and likely over $1.1 trillion by 2012. In 2002 African American owned businesses accounted for 1.2 million of the US's 23 million businesses, and 47% of Africans Americans own their own homes. So the kind of dysfunctional Black people commonly being portrayed in the media are a minority of the Black community, but they are a highly vocal, flamboyant, and inordinately publicized minority.
    .
    If White people were portrayed in the media in the same way as Black people, we'd think that the majority of White folks were barefooted Hillbillies. So if you’re a Black person and reading this article, simply look at your own situation, and that of your family and friends. The chances are overwhelming that you and your close associates are living at a level comparable to the average White middle-class individual. The same is true of myself, my family, and virtually all of my friends.
    .

    So the Black community is doing itself a huge disservice by just sitting back and allowing ourselves to be portrayed in this distorted and negative fashion. It sends the wrong message to our children. When they sit around for hours on end watching the antics of Lil’ Wayne and others flaunting the very worst of who we are, it sends the message to our young people that they have a moral obligation to be stupid in order to demonstrate their Black pride. They’re, literally, being instructed in what it means to be Black by sources other than ourselves. They’re being taught that being Black means wearing pants saggin’ off their asses, engaging in reckless and irresponsible behavior, scarring their bodies with ugly tattoos that can prevent them from obtaining employment, and giving priority to chasing "bling," momentary pleasure, and superficial trinkets over pursuing education, knowledge, and investing in themselves as individuals.
    .
    If we’re tolerating these things in our homes, we have no right to complain when the rest of society refuse to hire us, and profile us a superficial and irresponsible idiots. But the fact is, we’re not only tolerating it, we’re making people filthy rich by supporting an industry that thrive on producing videos that are nothing short of ten minute commercials being circulated around the world saying that the very womb of our culture are sluts and whoes who are only good for abuse, and that Black men want everything out of life but a job - and will do anything to get it.
    .
    That’s not who we are as a people, but that’s the way we’re being portrayed. That’s who our young people are looking up to, and that’s the way the rest of the world sees us. So if we allow this to continue, whose fault is it when the rest of the world believes their lying eyes? No wonder unemployment is so high among Black people. I wouldn’t hire anyone like that either - would you?
    .
    So the Black community needs to come down on the media like a sledgehammer, and stop them from slandering our community. We also have to start letting our children know, in no uncertain terms, that stupidity’s not cute. We can't start to disseminate that message too soon, or too early in a child’s life, and since kids tend to gravitate toward those things that they’re rewarded for as "cool," it’s not enough to simply address this issue as individual parents - we might as well be spittin’ in the wind. We have to address this issue as a COMMUNITY.
    .
    We’ve got to let BET know that if they want the community’s continued support, they’re going to have to change their call letters to stand for Black Excellence Television, and their programming is going to have to reflect that. We have to make it clear to BET, MTV, and the rest of the media that if they want the support of the Black community that they’re going to have to air programming that’s consistent with our agenda as a community - programming that reflects manhood as having the character to face and defeat adversity, and strength as being tender enough to sooth the wounded feelings of a baby girl.
    .

    But in order to do that, we need an organized community, and a big obstacle to that is the self-serving poverty pimps among us who benefit from our suffering. We’ve got to eliminate these people. These are the ones who are primarily responsible for the plight that we currently find ourselves. When Martin and Malcolm were alive, the only thing they wanted from the White man was for him to leave us alone and allow us to live our lives in peace. My grandfather had a little verse that reflected their attitude. He used to say, "The only thing I want from this whole damn nation, is a pretty little wife, and a good foundation." I didn’t realize it at the time, but in that one little verse he was teaching me the meaning of life - and he had that, and more.
    .
    But after the death of Martin and Malcolm, the poverty pimps swopped in to try to take their place, but both their philosophy, and their agenda, were much different. They convinced the Black community that we couldn’t make it on our own. They convinced us that we were incapable of such a monumental feat. They told us that we needed the White man’s help to move forward, so it was incumbent upon us to hire them as our official emissaries to the White man. That was in the late sixties and early seventies. But since that time, the "emissaries" have all profited greatly, while we’ve been sitting on our hands suffering, whining, and begging for the past forty years, and still waiting for the White man’s response. Sure we want our piece of America's pie, but the only way to get that is by organizing and making ourselves a strong enough political force to DEMAND it, not pay poverty pimps $30,000 an hour speaking fees to talk about how unjustly we're being treated. First, we already know that; and secondly, the only one it's benefitting is the poverty pimp. We're actually PAYING him to help spread the word, and profile us, as an hopelessly inept culture.
    .

    So it’s time to bring the poverty pimp hustle to an end. We don’t need one voice speaking for millions; we need millions speaking with one voice. We also need to re-embrace our self-esteem, and begin to recognize who we are, what we represent, and the dignity of what we’ve managed to overcome. We're not puppies who need to be defended. We are a strong and vibrant people. One of our number has risen from the very bottom to become President of the United States. That's one of the most amazing accomplishments in the history of mankind. It's the equivalent of a captured slave rising to become the emperor of Rome, and it also speaks volumes about the American people's respect for excellence. But the poverty pimps have a vested interest in playing that down. They have a vested interest in playing you down.  
    .

    But our history is clear. In spite of the fact that many of us have been dragged through the pits of Hell, we've managed to come out the other side as well adjusted and relatively well educated individuals. A study was done that shows that a White man with felony conviction has an equal chance of being hired for a job as a Black man with a spotless record (http://ac360.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/09/study-black-man-and-white-felon-same-chances-for-hire/) That alone says it all. While we've been forced to engage in a 100 yard dash where our White counterparts were spotted 25 yards, we've still managed to remained competitive. So the fact is, adversity has made us MORE, rather than less.
    .
    So don't buy into the great American myth. Yes, there are Black people who are struggling and at the bottom of the heap, but there are also many White people in that very same condition, and, in spite of having every advantage in life. So if you're Black and middle class, you've remained competitive with your White peers in spite of the fact that you were forced to wear lead boots during the competition. So you have much to be proud of - and not just the superficial pride of having Black skin, as James Brown suggested, but a genuine pride in what you’ve accomplished IN SPITE of your Black skin. So let us not allow our detractors have us confuse WHAT we are, or the title on our door, with WHO we are. We should ALWAYS invest in ourselves, because a great man will ALWAYS be a great man, even if he's on Skid Row.
    .
    Some of the greatest minds I've ever known held court while sitting on empty milk crates in the parking lots of ghetto liquor stores. So I know who you are and what you're capable of, because I know who I am and what I'm capable of - thanks to you.
     

    RELATED ARTICLE
    .


     

     

    Eric L. Wattree
    Http://wattree.blogspot.com
    [email protected]
    Citizens Against Reckless Middle-Class Abuse (CARMA)
    .
    Religious bigotry: It's not that I hate everyone who doesn't look, think, and act like me - it's just that God does.
     

    Comments

    Very good read.  


    Thank you, TRK.


    "One of our number has risen from the very bottom to become President of the United States."

    You're talking about Obama? Don't recall him living in a ghetto - think his grandma was a bank VP and he went to a cherry Hawaii prep school. His mother was a PhD grad & worked abroad for the World Bank & US government. If that's the "very bottom", you're right, things are much better than the media tells us.


    What you say is true, but...

    The tragedy of racism in this country is that plenty of black people with those same credentials...and even more who had the native ability to gain those credentials... were denied entry.

    So while Obama didn't come from the bottom in an ordinary sense, most blacks start kinda sorta at the bottom, or at least behind as they journey up the ladder.

    So maybe Eric could at least excise "very" because there are many, many people who are very-er than Obama. And maybe "behind" would be better than "bottom."


    It's an article on how the media exaggerates how poorly blacks are doing, and then Wattree exaggerates how poorly the plight of our most famous black. Ironic, eh? No, Obama was never "behind". That was just campaign marketing.


    His color, not his class, put him "behind."

    He had to be extraordinarily gifted and lucky to get to the WH.

    This is the tragedy of racism. Even if you've got the smarts...even if you grew up middle class...even if you've got everything your white coevals have...you start a few steps behind because of your color and have to run a few steps faster to get even.

    You can see this in how he was treated after he was elected...

    You can see this when folks say he wouldn't gotten there had he not been black...

    As if he were some mediocrity and his color, instead of disqualifying him, was his only qualification for the highest office.

    I've often thought that if Obama's daughters had acted like, say, Sarah Palin's daughter, knocked up by an illiterate hockey player, he wouldn't have gotten within five states of the WH. Those headlines write themselves.


    Most understand Wattree's points.Obama had to produce a full form birth certificate. He had to prove that he wasn't a raging Black Liberation Theologist. Obama had to overlook an Arizona Governor waving a finger in his face. I do think there have been strong signals sent out that support Wattree's view that Obama was coming from the bottom in a political construct that wanted him to know his place.

     


    This diary wasn't about "political constructs" - it was about wealth & poverty - cash. Obama had plenty enough cash as a kid. The suggestion otherwise is wrong - he had a fairly normal middle-class upbringing in a fairly color-blind community. He had no great struggle, and pretending he did is insulting to people who've dealt with huge discrimination and poverty.

    But go ahead, I'm sure any statement Wattree makes can be defended in some weird universe.


    Others appreciated Wattree's  post. Perhaps you are biased?


    Yes, I'm biased - I don't like lies and bullshit, and waving it away afterwards.


    Others seemed to like the post. Continue with your rant.


    Peter,

    have this same discussion with some Black people who maintain that Barack have the same kind of experiences as most Black people, and I tell them that they are right. Chances are, Obama's experiences were worse.

    Most Black people grow up in a Black cocoon, where they could avoid coming into contact with a lot of Blatant racism, but due to Obama’s family background, he always had to live as an outsider - that probably how he honed his coping skills, and it’s probably why many Black people don’t understand the way he copes with adversity. I wonder how many Black people could have coped with living in a White environment in the Republican stronghold of Kansas? I’m sure that I certainly wouldn’t have wanted to try it.

    In addition, even though Obama had a White family, from what I’ve read, he had to suffer many more hardships than my kids, or the kids of many of my Black associates, growing up. I just wrote an article to that effect. All my kids know about hardship are the stories I used to tell them. My kids grew up getting what they wanted, when they wanted. So what many White people think of as the "Black economic experience" is a myth. One day I took my son to by him some $40 sneakers, and he just laughed at me, and then came home and told his sister about it, and she laughed at me. Just a couple of months ago they had all of their friends laughing at me online talking about the time I brought my daughter a genuine waist-length fur coat home when she was in high school. They called it a poodle-skin coat. I had to give it me grandmother, and she was so happy to get it that it almost brought her to tears.

    So this belief that many White people have that most Black families are struggling by on $25K a year is a myth. My late wife made $37K a year MORE than I did. That’s just the way the media wants to portray us - like we spend all of our waking hours trying to figure out how to get the Tea Party to support us, while the fact is, a very large number of us make a lot more money than the people in the tea party. Like I said in my article, "Black People: Don’t Buy into the Great American Myth," if the media portrayed White people the way that they do Blacks, we’d think that most White folks were barefoot Hillbillies.

    The same is true of our intellect. There are many White people who are shocked when they find that we can read without moving our lips. But personally, I like that, and routinely take full advantage of it. It comes in handy when I'm dealing with people like Peracles (sic).  That guy makes me feel absolutely gifted.

     


    He never lived in Kansas - he lived in Hawaii with its multiethnic highly Asian population (as well as mixed servicemen), and in Indonesia where people are rather brown.

    His grandmother was a bank VP and he lived with her from 10 years on. Don't think he suffered hardship in this period, and likely his grandparents helped out a lot when he was little - doubt he ever missed a meal.

    In 2006, 40% of black families made $25K or less. Median black household income in 2011 was $33K - i.e. 50% of black familes make less than the difference between your late wife's pay and yours.

    As for the slur against me, I've worked with black execs and engineers and businessmen / entrepreneurs, as well as musicians and dealers and guys whose peak in life was working in a car wash. I don't recall any of them moving their lips when they read, along with whatever other stereotypes you have of them or me. Even the drunk working the carwash was bright & funny in his sober moments.


    I have less than zero interest in questioning the call for a collective "Black" community incentive to work against the double standards I see applied all the time in my daily life. But the last sentence of the following sticks in my craw:

    So don't buy into the great American myth. Yes, there are Black people who are struggling and at the bottom of the heap, but there are also many White people in that very same condition, and, in spite of having every advantage in life.

    That is an exquisitely racist thing to say.

     


    I see what you're saying, but...

    But from the perspective of a black person, they do have every advantage, or at least one overriding advantage even if they're not very advantaged in other ways.


    My comment was not a protest reminding people that poor white people have it hard too. It was directed at the hypocrisy of Wattree militating against the use of economic status to make comparisons between different groups' accomplishments followed by making exactly that kind of comparison himself:

    "but there are also many White people in that very same condition, and, in spite of having every advantage in life."

    The comparison is the reverse image of that used by racists who say affirmative action policies put Black people in jobs they did not deserve to have on the basis of merit. In other words, it is another way to say: How fucked up can these white people be to be living like this when they have all the advantages denied to black people?


    It's not the individual white people who are the problem, it the system. Judicial system and wage disparities persist. Black face harsher sentences for similar crimes and lower wages for similar work. There have been studies noting that a "black-sounding" name can result in being denied housing just over the phone. Similar named-based denials occur on job applications. There is a White Privilege.

     


    To clarify. Being being poor is detrimental for everyone, but there is a tendency for less resources to be available for minorities.Even when disasters like Katrina or Sandy strike, it is harder for minority groups to get relief compared to whites.

     


    In my comments above, I am not arguing that a White Privilege does not exist. On the contrary, I began by acknowledging its pervasive quality. Your statement is not the same as saying a group is poor "despite having every advantage."


    Not sure I understand your point entirely.

    Here's how I see what Eric is saying...

    • Blacks are stereotyped in the media as being much worse off, economically, than they are. This stereotype is based on stereotypes about black talent, intelligence, etc.

    (Eric may be saying that the majority of blacks are, in fact, doing as well as the majority of whites--which I'm not sure is true based on the numbers I read, but leaving this aside for the moment.)

    • Blacks shouldn't buy into this stereotypical portrayal of them.

    • Some blacks, however, aren't doing well. But they, too, shouldn't buy into this stereotype about blackness=poor, because some whites are also doing as poorly as they are, even without having to face the discrimination blacks face.

    IOW, poor blacks' economic status has little to do, inherently, with their color. This is his point, IMO. It has less to do with how fucked up poor whites are than with trying to counter the stereotype that blackness=poverty.

    Eric is wrong, in my view, to say these poor whites "have every advantage in life." They have one, overriding advantage over blacks, and while it's a big one, it's not the only one, and it's not necessarily decisive in their own success or failure. To put it another way, a white person's success or failure doesn't necessarily, and often doesn't, have anything to do with how well or poorly his black neighbor is doing. Any given white person may have all kinds of strikes against him that tend to make him less successful than any number of other people, white, black or Asian.

    Edit to add: Put it a different way. A white person's success or failure mostly has little to do with the color advantage he has over a black person. Perhaps, if a black person and a white person are competing for the same job--if they are competing directly--then society's racial stereotypes can enter in.

    Of course, if you're looking at the two "groups" at a macro level, you can say that some portion of white success has been achieved at the expense of black failure. But you have to keep the macro view and the individual view separate. You also have to separate out the idea that blacks are doing poorly because of social conditions and the view that blacks are doing poorly because of some inherent lack. Unfortunately, racists conclude the latter based on the former.


    Peter, you said,

    "Put it a different way. A white person's success or failure mostly has little to do with the color advantage he has over a black person. Perhaps, if a black person and a white person are competing for the same job--if they are competing directly--then society's racial stereotypes can enter in."

    Black man and white felon – same chances for hire

    http://ac360.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/09/study-black-man-and-white-felon-sa...



     


    Good point.


    Latest Comments