Larry Jankens's picture

    My Favorite Civil Liberty: Stupidity

    In these times of intense political discourse (or non-discourse if you're so inclined) it's nice to be reminded why you love this country: our civil liberties.

    Many people don’t realize that our most sacred freedom in America isn’t explicitly mentioned in the Bill of Rights, nor in any Supreme Court brief.  Yet, it is inherent in the theoretical underpinnings of this country’s Constitution; it’s the freedom of stupidity - perhaps the most widely used liberty.

    At its core, the Constitution and in particular the Bill of Rights mean to ensure the freedom for people to make decisions for themselves; they make no stipulation as to the intelligence of those decisions.  The only freedoms the Constitution prohibits are those that infringe upon other citizens rights to act freely. So as long as your stupidity doesn't directly endanger others, you have the implicit right to be stupid.  It’s what makes us American – the freedom of choice, the choice to be stupid.

    The freedom of stupidity is represented in the Bill of Rights and its notion of the free market of ideas.  The freedom of speech, religion, assembly, and due process ensure that individuals freely make decisions for themselves without government interference, thus the free market of ideas.  The Bill of Rights ensures that an individual can choose to be stupid and use his/her freedom speech for something completely stupid, racist bull-ish, for instance.  We all have a right to participate in the free market place of ideas, even if you are a stupid arsehole. It sounds strange to say, but that is the beauty of America: you have the choice to be an i.

    As with any free market, there are going to be good products and bad products; it is up to the individual consumer to decide which ideas will thrive and which will fail in the market.  The consumers, making rational decisions for themselves, drive the market.  If market forces prevail, stupid ideas, like racism, will fail while good ideas, like equality, will triumph.  It is a beautiful thing because it is the people making the decisions on what is good and what is bad, and not the government.

    Any investor will tell you, the market ain’t always grand. America’s free market of ideas is no different.  We have had some rough patches in our history: genocide of the natives, slavery, war, war, and more war, but the market worked properly and there were corrections.  People eventually realized the ideas they bought into are stupid and invested in better ideas.   It wasn’t always pretty and we have much more progress to make, but isn’t it better that the people decide what the market will bare than the government?

    Our founding fathers understood that a free society must allow people to think for themselves without overt government interference, even if it meant allowing them to be stupid.  I’ll be the first one to tell you I disdain bigoted homophobic idiot arseholes, but I accept them as a necessary evil to the free market of ideas.  Because freedom for all things, all the time, and the freedom to be stupid are inseparable. “All” is the operative word – as in “all ideas” – smart or stupid.  It is that idea that has allowed America to survive and progress.

    So next time you make a completely stupid decision, thank our Founding Father's faith that you will learn your lesson and not be such an idiot in the future.  Thank them for the freedom of stupidity.

     

    Topics: 

    Comments

    Wonderful. I think I have a nice little rejoinder:


    I watched up to level 5. I have no idea why. The little bacteria dudes on the left are sort of mesmerizing.


    I was stuck on the pills and how as the music got to the end, the pill dropping was very "destructive" to the goal.


    I accept bigoted homophobic idiot arseholes too. I just wish they weren't my neighbors.


    Me too, but remember: they will always lose! Ideas of equality, liberty, and justice will always defeat the ideas bigotry, tyranny, and injustice. At least I hope so, otherwise I'll move to Canada, eh?

    I'm not moving to Canada. Then Quinn would be my neighbor and it would basically be a wash.

    Wow, that was harsh. Even for me.

    Quinnie, I don't think you're equivalent to bigots. Not even close. 

    But I'm still never moving to Canada.


    And I'm never moving to Orlando. So there!


    I'm still in tears over Orlando's vicious insult, but thanks for the support acanuck.

    Sniff.


    Yeah, I'm never moving to Orlando either. Blech.

    Now, I'm liberal, but to a degree

    I want everybody to be free

    But if you think that I'll let Barry Goldwater

    Move in next door and marry my daughter

    You must think I'm crazy

     

    I wouldn't do it for all the farms in Cuba


    I'm not sure that I buy the stupid ideas fail in the marketplace of ideas theory. Isn't it about time for folks to sell off Rush Limbaugh? Also, the mullet.

    Though "life, libery, and stupidity" does have a nice ring to it.


    One could only hope, and yet I had my good friend arguing that the listener base of Rush far exceeded the following of NPR.

    He is glad to pay to listen to the man.


    Re: Rush - There will always be stupid people making stupid choices (listening to the ignorant Rush Limbaugh) in the market place.  Statistically, a little under half of the population is below average intelligence.  So about half the population is already at an intelligence disadvantage.  Let them have their Rush Limbaugh, reality TV, and top 40 radio - just don't let the morons run the country (oops too late).

    I would point to the election of Obama as a sign that the market place works: America rebuked the idiocy of the Reagan era (1980-2008) so resolutely they elected a black guy.  A BLACK GUY? PRESIDENT OF AMERICA?  I'm still incredulous, elated, but incredulous.  People must have really wanted a change from the stupid policies of the Reagan era to elect a black guy. 


    I would argue (how coherently, I am not sure) that Obama represents a return to the Reagan era. Albeit the more progressive version.

    Very generational.


    I think many here might consider those fighting words. I don't, but I'm not convinced by them, either. Reagan was no Reagan, that's for sure, which might be a basis for your comparison. Reagan oversaw the largest increase in the federal deficit up to that point. (A record that has since been shattered, of course.) Obama might very well set a new record there, although in this case, I'm not sure of a better alternative. (I very much hate deficit spending, and always have. As the Republicans suddenly seemed to have figured out, it's passing the buck onto future generations. Again, this is a special case, and spending less might result in bigger deficits in the end. Yuck. That argument sounds suspiciously like the Republican argument that cutting taxes will actualy increase revenues.)

    Anyways, I'm interested in why you think Obama might represent a return to the Reagan era, and look forward to the fireworks as you attempt to defend your position. ;)


    Speaking of Rush Limbaugh, I spent three hours in the car today, going to see my mom and taking her to a doctor's appointment. So, I tuned my dial to the AM side just for kicks. In no time at all, I was belly laughing. I get so mad when I read about the things Rush says, but when I hear them coming out of his mouth in context, during his show, they're just too ridiculous to take seriously. I mean it. Belly laughing. The drivers in the cars next to me probably thought I needed my meds.

    The best line of the show? They're calling the NYC plane debacle "Scare Force One." Now that's comedy.


    Orlando, I wish I had your sense of humor. I have tried to listen to the Limpball 4 different times and I can't go more than 15 minutes. I have a nephew that listened to him for years and hung on to every word as gospel truth. Having a conversation with my nephew could be difficult.

    I didn't think he was funny when his people were in power and ruining the country. But now that they keep insisting they are relevant and keep nit-picking the president, trying to find something that will stick, it makes me laugh and laugh and laugh. I know I'll stop laughing when something does eventually stick. But for now, it's entertaining.

    Is stupidity a civil liberty?  I thought it was an element:

    Some scientists claim that hydrogen, because it is so plentiful, is the basic building block of the universe. I dispute that. I say there is more stupidity than hydrogen, and that is the basic building block of the universe.

    - Frank Zappa


    Love the Frank Zappa quote!

    How about Einstein's take:

    Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe.


    Latest Comments